Week 4
Becoming an Author with Purpose
Becoming an Author with Purpose
Week Breakdown
Monday the 23rd
Write down Lexicon #37: Authorial choice and Lexicon #38: Metaphor, extended metaphor in your notebook.
We'll craft metaphors with the metaphor dice to illustrate how easy we can read into things and create our own compelling metaphors.
Introduce the Unit 3 Final Assignment: Author's Note: This Means Something.
Begin sketching your first draft of your piece. Remember, we'll have multiple drafts, each being graded to make sure we are following the writing process.
Tuesday the 24th
Take notes on the types of conflict found in literature.
Consider some of the situations or conflicts for your short story.
Take notes on clauses in the mini-grammar lesson on building confidence with clauses.
Complete first draft of your short story today, a minimum of two pages. Remember, this is a draft, so you don't have to be married to anything yet!
Wednesday the 25th
We'll be peer editing our stories today, working towards a complete draft by Thursday.
Before we delve into it, we will look at one of Mr. Roberts' models, suggesting what we like (praise), things we are confused about (questions), and potential revisions for improvement (polish).
After we got the feel of Praise, Question, and Polish, we will swap papers with a peer and give them some constructive feedback.
Once we get our feedback, we will have time to continue writing our stories, hoping to arrive at the turning point or larger conflict moment of the story (page 3 or 4).
Thursday the 26th
Mr. Roberts will start conferencing with students today and finish Friday while we make our finishing touches.
Review the 6 ways to authentically add metaphors into our writing.
We'll be focusing on adding meaning, foreshadowing, metaphors, allusions, and symbols into our pieces. By the end of the day, we should have a working full draft of the story or at least four pages.
Friday the 27th
Mr. Roberts will finish conferencing with students.
We'll go over 8 potential ways to end the story (there are more, but these are just some options!).
We'll be adding the five footnotes, polishing the final draft, typing up the story today. If typing isn't available, then we can handwrite it neatly.
When you are done, you can submit it one of three ways:
Submit it on our Google Classroom website.
Email me a copy of your short story from Word Doc or Google Doc. My email is Droberts@Bostonpublicschools.org
Handwrite it and hand in your Notebook, or alternatively, handwrite it and email me a picture of it to Droberts@Bostonpublicschools.org.
Monday the 23rd
Choosing to read into things
Lexicon #37: Authorial choice
Definition: The deliberate decisions a writer makes in crafting a story to shape meaning, develop characters, and impact the reader. These choices include elements like point of view, structure, dialogue, tone, imagery, and what is revealed or withheld. Each choice contributes to the overall effect and purpose of the narrative.
Lexicon #38: Metaphor, extended metaphor
Definition: A metaphor is a direct comparison between two unrelated things to suggest a shared quality or deeper meaning, without using “like” or “as.”
An extended metaphor takes this comparison further by continuing it throughout a portion—or the entirety—of a text, developing the symbolic connection over time.
Example
Dice: My father = broken + mirror
My father is a broken mirror
which is to say
he has been shattered,
but I can still see myself in the pieces
Instructions
Step 1: Pick one of the rolled metaphors.
Step 2: Write it down in your notebook adding "is" or "is not" (or the equivalent) to complete it.
For example, "Memory is a flawed trophy" or "Memory is not a flawed trophy."
Step 3: Write the phrase "which is to say" below it and expand upon it until it makes sense!
If you were absent, here are some pre-rolled dice for you to do at home or for make-up!
Unit 3 Final Assignment (20% of quarter grade)

Tuesday the 24th
We write to discover!
Conflict Types
Character vs. Nature: A struggle between a character and natural forces (weather, animals, disease, survival in the wild).
Character vs. Character: A conflict between two characters, often the protagonist and antagonist, involving direct opposition or clashing goals.
Character vs. God (or Fate): A struggle against destiny, divine will, or higher powers beyond human control; often existential or spiritual.
Character vs. Society: A character challenges laws, norms, or societal expectations; fights for justice, freedom, or change.
Character vs. Self: An internal struggle with personal doubts, fears, guilt, or moral dilemmas.
Character vs. No God: A crisis of meaning in a world where divine presence or purpose is absent; often linked to nihilism or existential despair.
Character vs. Technology: A character struggles against machines, AI, or the consequences of technological advancement.
Character vs. Reality: A character questions what is real; conflict with hallucinations, delusions, simulations, or a distorted perception of the world.
Character vs. Author: A meta-conflict where a character becomes aware of or rebels against the author’s control or narrative structure.
Discovering our Plot through Conflict
Internal (Character vs. Self)
A character is about to send a text but deletes it.
They rehearse a lie in the mirror but can’t say it aloud.
They stand outside a door they’re afraid to open.
Relationships (Character vs. Character)
A secret is accidentally revealed at a family gathering.
A friend betrays a promise or spreads a rumor.
A confrontation begins quietly but escalates fast.
Societal (Character vs. Society)
A character gets rejected from something they deserve (job, school, grant).
They're told to “change” to fit in—name, accent, style.
They're surveilled, profiled, or punished unfairly.
Survival (Character vs. Nature)
A storm cuts off power and forces characters together.
A character navigates unfamiliar land or terrain.
Nature overwhelms them physically/emotionally (heat, flooding, darkness).
Tech/Supernatural (Character vs. Tech or Fate)
A character receives an ominous notification.
Their GPS leads them somewhere wrong—or right.
Today's goal: Finish the first draft (at least two pages)
A clear character
Your protagonist could have a name, identity, particular quirks about them, or something they want or struggle with.
Readers should have a sense of who they are—even if they’re still developing.
A conflict
There should be tension, struggle, or a challenge that drives the story forward. (Check out the conflict types for inspiration.
A conflict can be internal (inside themselves) or external (other people) or both!
A setting
Where and when does the story happen? Give us some description to help us picture it. Make it feel lived in by the characters instead of an empty space.
At least one full scene
We want to see the story unfold—not just be told what happened.
Include dialogue, action, and inner thoughts to show conflict or emotion.
Mini-grammar lesson: Confidence with Clauses
Know Your Clauses
A complete sentence in the English language follows the formula: Subject + Verb + Object, or SVO for short.
Independent Clause = a complete sentence
Example: She runs every morning.
Dependent Clause = an incomplete idea; needs support.
Example: Because she runs every morning
Quick Check:
Mark I for independent and D for dependent:
___ I went to the store.
___ While it was raining.
___ Because I was tired.
___ We ate dinner together.
Connecting Independent Clauses (two full sentences)
To connect two independent clauses, or full sentences, correctly use
A comma + coordinating conjunction (for, and, nor, but, or, yet, so)
Example: She was tired, but she kept working.A semicolon ;
Example: She was tired; she kept working.
Try it:
Connect these two independent clauses:
“She was late.” + “She didn’t apologize.”
Add an Introductory Clause
Introductory clauses set the stage and are followed by a comma. Introductory clauses start with conditional words like "after," "although," "as," "because," "before," "if," "since," "through," "until," "when," while," and "to" and then end with a comma to connect it to another independent clause (complete sentence).
Example: Although it was late, we kept working.
Example: After the show, they went out to eat.
Try it:
Add an introductory clause:
“___________ , he finally replied to the message.”
Style with Nonrestrictive Clauses
Nonrestrictive clauses use commas with words like "who," "which," and "especially" to add extra, non-essential info. They often come towards the end of a sentence, but you can be set off in the middle of a sentence like the first two examples.
Example #1: My brother, who lives in Chicago, is visiting.
Example #2: The novel, which was published in 1960, is still widely read.
Example #3: The report was quite telling of the person he was, especially the part about the murders.
Try it:
Add a nonrestrictive clause:
“My favorite food is fruit,___________ .
Wednesday the 25th
Praise, Question, and Polish
Directions: Decide on how you'd like to read each other's work. Some people may like to swap, read, then provide feedback afterwards, while someone else may want to read it to the author or have the author read it to them. Whichever you choose, be sure to provide comments for each category. Write as many comments as you can.
Praise: What do you like about my story? What works well? What are some specific examples of things that you thought were done well?
Question: What are some things that you did not understand in my story? Are there questions that you have about why I wrote the story the way that I did? What are some parts of my story that you felt were left unfinished or not fully explored?
Polish: What could I do specifically to make this a better story? What parts would you change and how?
Mr. Roberts' Examples

Today's goal: Revising and Improving
Reflect on peer feedback: Identify one piece (praise, question, or polish) that will shape your edits today.
Revise your draft using feedback from conferencing and peer review. Focus on clarity, style, and development.
Continue writing your story: our daily goal is to reach page 3 or 4 of your short story.
Make sure you hit a major plot point or begin the turning point in your narrative.
Thursday the 26th
Adding meaning and foresight into our stories
Foreshadowing what's to come!
What’s something the reader should feel by the end? Now, what small detail can you plant early that hints at that?
Plant small details early: A broken clock, a character’s strange reaction, a phrase overheard—something that doesn’t stand out but comes back with weight later.
Use repetition: If something appears more than once (an object, image, line of dialogue), it starts to feel important—like a clue.
Weather or setting shifts: A storm brewing, lights flickering, an unexpected silence—can subtly signal change or tension ahead.
Turning the Ordinary into Symbols!
What object keeps showing up in your draft? Can it represent a larger idea or feeling?
Choose an object or idea that can carry layered meaning (a key, a tree, a song).
Make it appear in key moments—maybe it changes, breaks, is lost, etc.
Symbols work best when they grow with the character or plot.
Alluding to our Inspirations!
Can we sneak in a reference that would strengthen our understanding of a character, their motives, their relationships, their actions, etc.?
Create references to pop culture, myths, the Bible, classic lit, TV shows, anime, events in history, or fairy tales
Allusions can be subtle: A character who’s “waiting for a sign” might echo Penelope waiting for Odysseus.
Use for irony, contrast, or depth—referencing Romeo & Juliet in a breakup scene.
6 Ways to Add Metaphors Authentically
1. Connect Emotions to the Physical World
Ask yourself: What does this feeling feel like in the body?
“Her anxiety sat on her chest like a stack of bricks.”
“His guilt clung to him like the smell of smoke.”
Tip: Choose textures, weights, or natural forces (wind, gravity, water) to describe internal states.
2. Use the Setting as a Mirror
Let the environment reflect the character’s mood or growth.
“The cracked sidewalk matched the way she felt inside.”
“Sunlight spilled in, as if the room itself had taken a breath.”
Tip: Look at the weather, landscape, or room details—what could reflect the character’s situation?
3. Make a Character Think in Metaphor
People naturally compare things. Use metaphors in narration or internal monologue.
“Trying to talk to her was like chasing smoke.”
“He was a puzzle with half the pieces missing.”
Tip: Think about what the character would compare things to based on their world (sports, music, mechanics, food, etc.).
4. Choose a Central Metaphor and Extend It
Pick a big image or theme and run with it throughout. This becomes a controlling metaphor or motif.
If the story is about grief → use metaphors of drowning, shadows, echoes.
If it’s about freedom → use wings, cages, open doors.
Tip: Let the metaphor evolve. If a character starts caged, maybe the door opens near the end.
5. Turn Objects into Metaphors
Find everyday things that could mean more, ask yourself What object keeps showing up in my story? What could it symbolize?
A mirror = identity or reflection
A broken phone = communication problems
A stained shirt = something you can’t hide
6. Use Contrasts, Ironic, or Unexpected Metaphors
Great metaphors often surprise:
“Her love was a war, and he didn’t know which side he was on.”
"He was a lighthouse in the fog—brilliantly useless."
“His voice was sugar-sweet but left cavities.”
Today's goal: Integrate a metaphor, add dialogue, and get to the ending!
Add meaning: Consider the ways we can add a metaphor, foreshadowing, symbols, and allusions into our work.
Remember the requirements: We need one moment where we have dialogue (at least two people talking) and find somewhere to add a metaphor!
Try to get to the ending... or near it! Our goal page wise today would be 4 pages, but we can meet you where you are at. If you're at 2 pages, let's try to get to the 3rd!
Friday the 27th
Polishing and Finalizing our Short Stories
How do I end it? 8 Potentials ways to wrap it up!
1. Full-Circle Ending
Bring the story back to an image, phrase, or theme from the beginning.
Example: If the story opened with the character packing a suitcase, end with them unpacking it in a new place—or hesitating to do so.
Good for: Stories about growth, transitions, or reflection.
2. Open-Ended or Ambiguous Ending
Leave the final moment unresolved to reflect the uncertainty of real life.
Example: A character stands outside a door, unsure whether to enter. The story ends with them reaching for the doorknob.
Good for: Themes of identity, belonging, or choices that don’t have easy answers.
3. Epiphany Ending
End with a realization or shift in the character’s mindset, even if their situation hasn’t changed.
Example: A character accepts that they will always feel torn between two cultures—but that it’s not a flaw, it’s a feature.
Good for: Stories where internal change is more important than external events.
4. Twist Ending
Introduce an unexpected turn that recontextualizes the story.
Example: The narrator has been speaking in the third person about a "friend" or "cousin"—but it turns out it's their own story.
Good for: Stories that play with narrative perspective or family dynamics.
5. Bittersweet Ending
Mix hope with loss. Maybe something is gained, but at a cost.
Example: A character achieves a goal (like learning English or getting a job) but realizes they’ve lost part of their connection with home.
Good for: Realistic stories where gains come with sacrifices.
6. Symbolic or Poetic Ending
End with a powerful image, metaphor, or line that captures the emotional truth of the story.
Example: A child watches planes cross the sky, wondering if they’ll ever fly in the other direction.
Good for: Strong writers or stories that are theme-driven.
7. Flash-Forward Ending
Jump into the future to show how things turn out.
Example: A character reflects as an adult on a moment from childhood that they now see differently.
Good for: Stories about growth, memory, or generational shifts.
8. Quiet Ending
Don’t go big—go intimate. End on a small gesture or quiet moment that says everything.
Example: A character fixes their father's collar before his first job interview in the U.S.
Good for: Character-driven stories with emotional depth.
How to Create Footnotes
To add a footnote, highlight the word or sentence, then click "Insert" and head down to "Footnote."
What it looks like on Google Docs
Footnote page (if you find "add footnote" function tough)
On your separate page, copy and paste a line, sentence, or section you want to comment on (making sure you put it in quotations marks), and write your 1-3 sentence explanation afterwards.
For example,
"He was a firm believer of the old adage: 'A chain is only as strong as its weakest link.' And when it came to family, his son was always the link in": Here, I wanted to play with the whole saying and connect it to the father-son relationship. It's where I'm beginning the issue that the dad looks down on his son, who only wants his approval.
Submitting your final, polished draft of your short story
Three ways to submit it
Submit it on Google Classroom: Though You can submit it on Google classroom.
Email it to me: You can write it on a Google Doc or Word Doc and email it to me (droberts@Bostonpublicschools.org).
Handwrite it and then hand it in physically: You can handwrite it and hand it to me physically or taking a picture and emailing me (droberts@Bostonpublicschools.org) the whole short story with footnotes.
Assignment's Requirements
4-5 pages double-spaced, 12 point font, Times New Roman or similar font style.
Includes one moment of dialogue (at least two people talking) with proper formatting of quotation marks and dialogue tags.
Includes at least one metaphor, extended metaphor, simile, or personification.
Includes five footnotes explaining five choices you made in the piece. Each explanation should be 1-3 sentences long -- it's okay to write more if needed!